Bronson Pope

Who knew there were any good guys left? Well, Bronson Pope seems to fit the bill. He's a non-creepy activist who does things above board, he's close to his family, he smells great, and he takes care of little animals. And when Mac freaks out about kissing him, he doesn't let that get in the way of a second date, which leads to more, and eventually to the grand prize in a Valentine's Day scavenger hunt...under the covers in Mac's cutely pink single bed. First love he's not, but Bronson comes across as nearly perfect, and that's a rarity in Neptune.

So, of course, it couldn't last.

The lure of bad boy Max and hot nerd-on-nerd action was just too strong for Mac. Too-good-to-be-true, Ultimate-Frisbee-playing, early-morning-hiking Bronson gets the "It's not you, it's me" routine that breaks his heart.